Why Does Lash Retention Vary So Much Between Clients? A Complete Guide for Technicians

"I apply extensions with the same care and technique for everyone, yet some clients have amazing retention while others shed quickly. Why?"

As a lash artist facing clients every day, have you ever asked yourself this question?

Lash extension retention isn't determined solely by the technician's skill. It is influenced by a diverse range of factors, including the condition of the client's natural lashes, their daily habits, and even the season or environment.

In this article, we will clarify the specific characteristics of clients with "Good Retention" versus "Poor Retention," and thoroughly explain the causes and countermeasures for each.

---

The Decisive Difference: "Good Retention" vs. "Poor Retention" Clients

What kind of client is sitting in front of you right now? Let's look at the defining traits.

Characteristics of Clients with Good Retention

Clients with excellent retention often unconsciously maintain an environment that is favorable for eyelash extensions.

1. Healthy and Strong Natural Lashes (With Moderate Flexibility)

• Each lash has firmness (body) and consistent thickness.

• The cuticles are intact and not damaged by mechanical curlers, lash perms, or friction. This allows the glue to adhere firmly.

• Importantly, they possess moderate flexibility. This helps the extension blend with the natural lash, preventing the "spring-back" effect where the lash pops off.

2. A Stable Lash Cycle

• They have many lashes in the "Anagen" (growth) phase.

• The shedding cycle is relatively slow, meaning the extension stays on the natural lash for a longer period before the natural lash falls out.

3. Proper Aftercare Habits

• They use oil-free cleansing products designed for extensions and wash gently.

• They dry their face by blotting gently with a towel, never rubbing.

• They do not have a habit of rubbing their eyes.

• They sleep on their back to avoid friction against the pillow.

• They use a lash serum regularly to maintain the health of their natural lashes.

4. No Unconscious Touching

• They do not touch, pick, or fiddle with their eyes or lashes during the day.

Characteristics of Clients with Poor Retention

Conversely, clients who struggle with retention often exhibit the following traits:

1. Weak/Damaged Lashes OR Lashes that are Too Stiff

• Damaged: Fine, soft hair (vellus hair) or lashes with stripped cuticles due to friction or curling tools. These lashes cannot support the weight of the extension or provide a stable bonding surface.

• Oily/Dry: Excessively dry lashes or oily lashes (due to oily skin or leftover makeup) prevent the glue from curing or bonding correctly.

• Too Stiff: If natural lashes are extremely thick with too much tension, a phenomenon called "Spring-back" can occur. The natural lash tries to straighten out, repelling the extension and causing the base to lift.

2. Unstable or Fast Lash Cycle

• Stress, hormonal changes, or seasonal transitions can disrupt the lash cycle. If extensions are applied to lashes near the end of their life cycle, they will shed quickly.

3. Improper Aftercare and Lifestyle Habits

• Using skincare or makeup containing heavy oils.

• Scrubbing the eyes aggressively during face washing.

• Leaving lashes wet after showering (weakens the glue bond).

• Sleeping face-down (stomach sleeper), causing friction against the pillow.

• Unconsciously rubbing eyes or pulling at lashes.

• Using mechanical curlers or non-extension-safe mascara over the extensions.

4. Failure to Follow Salon Advice

• They understand the importance of aftercare but find it troublesome and skip steps.

---

Why the Gap? The Multifaceted Factors Influencing Retention

Now that we know the characteristics, let's dig deeper into the "Why." Retention is determined by a complex interplay of elements.

1. The Condition of the Client's Natural Lashes (The Foundation)

• Lash Cycle: Lashes go through Growth (Anagen), Transition (Catagen), and Resting (Telogen) phases. Attaching to a hair in the late Telogen phase means it will fall out very soon regardless of application quality.

• Texture & Health: Damaged or thin hair has poor surface area for adhesion. Oily lashes create a barrier against the glue.

• The "Spring-back" Phenomenon: This is a unique challenge with healthy, thick lashes. Because the hair core is strong, it resists the curl of the extension. It tries to return to its original shape, physically pushing the extension away before the glue fully sets, leading to early lifting.

• Growth Direction: Downward-pointing lashes or lashes with erratic growth directions make it difficult to secure a sufficient bonding area.

2. The Client's Lifestyle and Aftercare

• Cleansing: Oil degrades glue. Friction physically rips extensions off. Residue creates a barrier.

• Sleeping Position: Stomach sleeping causes massive mechanical stress on the lashes.

• Touching: Oils from fingers and physical pulling are major causes of premature shedding.

• Wet Lashes: Cyanoacrylate (glue) degrades when exposed to moisture for long periods. Leaving lashes wet speeds up glue breakdown.

3. Technician Technique and Environment

• Glue Selection: Using the right adhesive for your speed and humidity levels.

• Pre-treatment: If dirt and oils aren't perfectly removed, the bond will fail.

• Application Skills: Securing the correct bonding surface area (attachment), proper angle, and distance from the lid (1-2mm).

• Handling "Spring-back": Thick lashes require specific techniques (holding the isolation/placement longer) to ensure the bond sets before the lash repels it.

• Environment: Humidity and temperature control are non-negotiable for glue performance.

---

Actionable Steps: How Technicians Can Improve Retention

Understanding the causes is half the battle. Here is what you can do as a professional to help your clients.

1. Strengthen Counseling and Education

This is the first step to resolving doubts and encouraging proper care.

• Detailed Hearing: Ask about lifestyle, sleeping positions, and skincare. If a client complains of poor retention, ask specific questions: "From which eye?", "When did they start falling out?", "Did the natural lash come out with it?"

• Explain the Lash Cycle: Educate them that shedding is natural and that individual differences exist.

• Demonstrate Aftercare: Don't just say "wash gently." Show them how to wash without friction and how to blow-dry lashes with cool air.

• Tailored Advice: Give specific tips based on their habits (e.g., "Since you sleep on your right side, try a silk pillowcase or a specialized eye mask").

2. Optimize Your Technique

Refine your professional skills to adapt to different lash types.

• Thorough Pre-treatment: Use a lash bath and primer to strip all oils and proteins. Clean between the layers and near the roots.

• Glue Management: Check for viscosity changes. Shake well. Replace the drop frequently. Ensure humidity is optimal.

• Application Precision:

  • The "Spring-back" Fix: For clients with thick, straight lashes, use a glue with slightly higher viscosity or hold the extension in place with your tweezers for a few extra seconds until the bond "locks."

  • wrapping: If using volume techniques, ensure the fan wraps the natural lash.

• Complete Drying: Ensure the glue is fully cured (nano-mister or fan) before the client opens their eyes to prevent shock curing or irritation.

3. Careful Product Selection

Suggest products that are gentle on lashes and prolong retention.

• High-Quality Glue: Use reliable, professional-grade adhesives.

• Retail Products: Recommend a specific lash serum to keep the natural lashes strong (a better foundation holds extensions longer). Sell lash-safe cleansers in your salon to remove the guesswork for the client.

4. Building Trust

Create an environment where clients feel safe discussing retention issues.

• Open Communication: Make it easy for them to tell you if lashes fell out too soon so you can fix it.

• Next Appointment Check: Always ask, "How was the retention last time?" before starting the new set. Adjust your glue or technique based on their answer.

• Feedback: Ask for honest feedback to show you care about their satisfaction.

---

Summary

Lash extension retention is a partnership. It is determined by a mix of your technical skill, the client's lash characteristics, and their lifestyle.

The answer to "Why does she have such good retention?" is usually hidden within this complex web of factors. While clients with good retention often create a good environment unconsciously, you must also be prepared to handle clients with "too healthy" lashes that cause spring-back.

By accurately assessing the client's lash condition, providing the optimal application technique, and offering thorough counseling, you can maximize retention.

View retention as a "Three-Legged Race" between you and the client. When you work together, your clients will enjoy their lashes longer, leading to higher satisfaction and repeat bookings.